"Skinny Legs is one of those rare points on the face of this dirty globe from which all good feelings emanate," says the magazine's review. "Travelers wash up at Skinny's for the harmonic convergence and stay for the rum punch and a cheeseburger grilled behind the bar in the open for all the world to smell."
The magazine tells the story that, "Dedicated bartenders and best friends Moe Chabuz and Doug Sica (from Lawrence, Massachusetts, and Red Bank, New Jersey) found a little spot by the water on the Coral Bay side of the island and started Skinny Legs in 1991, because the world just needed the place, Moe says. He and Doug put their last dime into it, and 'we did everything wrong,' but it's become the center of the Coral Bay community, and one of those joints you just never want to leave. So don't."
Here's a link to Esquire: http://www.esquire.com/bestbars/bb-SkinnyLegs